The National Consumer Tribunal has ruled against Pretoria restaurant TriBeCa Standard over its practice of automatically adding a 10% service charge to customers' bills.
The ruling follows an investigation by the National Consumer Commission (NCC), which found that the restaurant automatically applied the charge despite describing it as discretionary on its menu.
Customers who were dissatisfied with the service had to approach management and specifically request that the additional amount be removed from their bills.
The investigation revealed that the restaurant was processing approximately 200 service charge transactions daily.
The Tribunal found that the practice was unfair and contravened the Consumer Protection Act, which protects consumers against unfair business practices.
It ruled that while restaurants are permitted to accept gratuities, customers must have complete freedom to decide whether they want to leave a tip.
In its ruling, the Tribunal said: “A genuinely voluntary gratuity is one that the consumer freely elects to pay. It is not an amount automatically added to a bill and removed only if the consumer challenges it.”
The Tribunal further found that describing the charge as discretionary on the menu did not make the practice lawful.
The ruling reinforces that restaurants cannot automatically impose service charges on customers, even when these are presented as optional.
Customers must be allowed to decide whether to reward service with an additional payment, without having to request its removal from their bills.